Our evolving toddler TV policy, part II

Following up on my post about our evolving toddler TV policy, I have a few other thoughts on kids and screen time that I wanted to share:

  • The original post was in no way meant to cast aspersions on parents who let their toddlers watch more or less TV than we do.  Rather, it was intended to be a “here’s one approach and why we take it” post.  Just an example.  As with most parenting choices, there’s a wide range of options that are perfectly fine.  Unless you’re letting your two-year-old watch Game of Thrones, you’re probably OK.
  • When we’re sick, the rules largely go out the window.  I was feeling awful yesterday and Little Boy was getting over a bad cold, so we pretty much just camped in the living room and watched a rotation of Daniel Tiger’s Neighborhood, Curious George, and Sesame Street (for him), and Property Brothers and House Hunters (for me).  Except for when Sesame Street was on, Little Boy got bored and played with his toys instead.  I guess we technically weren’t violating our house rule against unsupervised TV, come to think of it.
  • The American Academy of Pediatrics’ policy against screen time starts by telling us that children aren’t learning from TV before age 2.  Which is fair, if a little conservative in my opinion.  Baby Einstein isn’t going to make your infant a genius.  The second part of the policy, though, warns us that parents speak fewer words when the TV is on, depriving kids of valuable interaction.  Here’s the thing, though: In reality, it’s not a choice between TV and a pair of ideal, chatty, energetic parents.  It’s a choice between TV and Little Boy’s real parents, who are sometimes tired, quiet, and introverted.  If the TV wasn’t on at times, we’d probably be watching Little Boy play while scanning the news on our iPads.  We do plenty of talking and reading and playing, but we’re real human beings and we don’t do those things 100% of the time, TV or no.

That last point is one that’s always worth bearing in mind, I think.  In parenting, you’re rarely making choices between something perfect and something not.  You’re making choices between two imperfect options and looking for the one that works best for your family.  And that’s going to depend a lot on who you are, and who your kid is, and what your circumstances are.  Anyone who says there’s One True Way is full of crap.

Advertisements

5 thoughts on “Our evolving toddler TV policy, part II

  1. I find one true way advocates bloody annoying. Unless they’re saying tomato soup is an abomination, which I can get behind 100%.

    Our screen time is an alternative to me shrieking ‘Nooooo! Get out of the kitchen!’. Of course sometimes it’s the boys shouting ‘Stop banging on the computer, baby!’ instead.

    Like

      • tomato soup is mushy? They’re not doing it right. Not that I’m a tomato soup evangelist, but I don’t mind having a bowl on occasion (maybe once a year).

        Re: TV time . . . I try to talk to my kid while we watch something. She doesn’t watch a lot. I sometimes let her watching Elmo’s World while she practices on the potty. I’m okay with all this. I figure that, as long as I’ve not using the TV for hours a day as a babysitter, I’m probably okay.

        But if it were okay to use the TV for hours a day as a babysitter, then I’m paying too much for daycare :-p

        Like

  2. Pingback: Our evolving toddler TV policy, part III | crazy grad mama

Reply to this post:

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s